I was disappointed that SB270 was carried over to 2025 (on the motion from Delegate Sickles) - and that no one on this subcommittee moved to report this bill to the full P&E Committee for further discussion and consideration. I would be pleased if SB270 was discussed further and open to a motion to report. There were some misstatements made on February 19th. A citizen, Mr. Jones, who testified remotely, referred to a "test election I think in Alexandria". He stated that it was a "fiasco, so much so that the governing body decided to never use it again." Let's get the facts straight. RCV was used in the County Board primary election in June 2023 in Arlington County. Arlington Elections office surveyed its officers after the election - over 90% of them reported that "most voters were aware of RCV" and that voters had "little to no questions" after they were instructed how to mark their ballots. One informal survey by ArlNow found less than 10% of respondents were confused about how to mark their ballots. The Arlington County Board conducted a survey of voters in June-July 2023. Results show that 57% of the (2,400) respondents rated their RCV experience as "exceptional" or "positive". 47% wanted to see RCV used in every election, with another 7% favoring its use in primary elections only. Mr. Jones was also incorrect in stating that the County Board decided never again to use RCV. In fact, in December 2023, they voted unanimously to use RCV in all future County Board primary elections. (Mr. Jones was also incorrect in suggesting that the winner of the June and November elections supported that vote "and it's back" -- they were not seated on the Board until January 2024). This weekend, the County Board is considering an ordinance to expand the use of RCV to the County Board General elections. Arlington County is ready to use RCV. Although Delegate Bloxom stated that using RCV was "not allowed in the Republican rules", may I point out that the Republican Party of Virginia used RCV in the 2021 gubernatorial primary - their winning slate garnered strong support from their voters and their ticket won all 3 statewide races. The Republican party also used RCV in two Congressional primary elections. Delegate Srinivasan similarly asked about Democratic Party rules about using RCV - the Democrats in various jurisdictions have, indeed, used RCV in some caucuses to select/endorse candidates. RCV is good for voters - it's good for candidates. Let's move this forward - with knowledge based on facts.

I support SB270 because having 45 days of early voting practically ensures some presidential candidates will drop out while the primary is in progress. Ranked choice would allow me to mark all the candidates with whom I would be satisfied. I wouldn't have to guess who would still be in the race 44 days later. Ranked choice would also benefit the party and the candidate by assuring them of majority, not just plurality, support. Some folks say a ranked choice ballot is too complicated but I've yet to meet anyone who had trouble with the various sample ballots ranking pizza toppings or candy. I hope you will report SB270.

As a member of a good governance group, BigMoneyOutVA, I support SB 270. Rank choice voting has been introduced in states and jurisdications around the country and has been effective in allowing citizens not to "waste" their vote. It is easy to understand and implement and it allows citizens to feel that a candidate wins with a plurarity of the votes. Also, as someone who worked overseas, this process of voting keeps my vote "in the game" even though candidates may have dropped out by the time my vote was counted. Please pass this bill.

HB1003 is a no brainer; I can't believe this notice of polling place changes isn't standard procedure already. Support HB1045 looks great as well, would be a huge step towards making elections more about who has the most popular ideas rather than who can raise the most money. Support HB375 is the main reason I'm commenting; the electoral college is outdated and provides voters in some states with much more power than others. Until the electoral college can be abolished by constitutional amendment, this compact is a great way of ensuring that ALL the people of this country choose its president, not just those in a few swing states. It saddens me to see how many people in the comments on this bill are against this common sense change. Major support SB270 is another no brainer; allowing voters to express their preferences beyond a winner take all system would be a huge win for democracy in the state of Virginia. Support

Dear Committee Members: Reference SB270: I have worked as an election officer, assistant chief, and chief for the past 5 years. I oppose Rank Choice Voting due to the following: 1) The possibility of many candidates to choose from which each voter must rank. For example, if there are 6 candidates, the voter must rank each candidate 1 – 6 by selecting the appropriate oval. The attached file shows an example of the instructions for Rank Choice voting ballot that took place at the Alaska’s Secretary of State election. 2) Will cause confusion for the voters which may lead to high percentage of spoiling ballots especially if they mistakenly selected two candidates as first choices even though the instructions are presented. 3) Forces the voters to rank a candidate they don’t support. 4) If the voter does not rank all candidates, most likely their ballot will not move forward to the next round which causes the voter’s ballot to be discarded which is not the American democratic way and their voices are silenced. 5) The results can be skewed by rigging counting software each time it runs multiple cycles. 6) Particularly damaging to vulnerable voters (military, seniors, mail voters) who are unable to immediately correct mistakes. 7) Hinders recounts and audits. 8) Expect longer lines. As a chief election officer, it is great to see voters come out to exercise their right to vote. Let us not discourage the voters by complicating the election process. Thank you for your time, Carmen Torres-Nisbet, a concern citizen

As a citizen of the United States of America and, more specifically, the Commonwealth of Virginia, I am appalled at the condition of our politics today. We have degraded to a point that the average citizen feels unmoved to vote because the choices we have are nasty and nastier. In this country we need to return to politics that are more about governance for the majority than sound bites to stir up negativity about our fellow Americans. Rank Choice Voting, or Instant Run-off Voting, will give us more options than only two parties, and will provide incentive for candidates to talk more about substance than vitriol. Voters will have more incentive to vote because their vote will have more weight. Please vote for bringing this issue to the full House for consideration. Sharon Barnes

I am writing in support of Ranked Choice Voting in Virginia Primaries. I love my country and served in the air force following my graduation from the Air Force Academy in 1970. It wounds me and grieves me to see America being ripped in half by extreme partisan politics. The two major political parties seem no longer able to work together for the good of the people they purport to represent. There are many reasons for this but some stand out. Gerrymandered districts find candidates competing to be the most extreme in order to represent their party in districts likely to be non-competitive in the general election. So legislatures wind up with too few moderates to bridge a wide chasm between their members, unable to cooperate with each other because to do so risks alienating their loudest (angriest?) constituents and risks as well their personal future political prospects (having consorted with the "enemy"). The end result is that CITIZENS' NEEDS ARE NOT MET as government dysfunction prevents reasonable compromise solutions. One step towards meeting the real everyday needs of Virginians is RANKED CHOICE VOTING. RCV is not a silver bullet, but it is a step toward restoring government functionality. RCV would help at every level but can be especially helpful in statewide elections where winning candidates are expected to serve a large and diverse population spread over a sizable area. As representatives currently serving your local district as well as feeling some patriotism for America and for Virginia, I am asking you please to give RCV your most serious consideration. You don't need me or anyone else to explain to you how RCV can move political discourse away from the non-productive edges and toward the result-oriented middle. You don't need me to explain the cost savings of counting election day voter preferences versus holding a run-off election. So I'll spare anyone reading this a long recitation of what is already well known. This year's primaries offer a great laboratory to conduct this experiment in rescuing our democracy, course correcting off the road to ruin which is now so dangerously in play. Even if the races are not expected to be close, we have an opportunity to begin to educate voters on the many reasons to adopt and practice RCV. No longer will a citizen who prefers a candidate with low poll numbers have to decide whether or not to vote for them, because they can do so with no fear of having "thrown away" their vote. (This may not hold if apportioning delegates just counts votes and does not require a majority to win in some states. But still there is NO DOWNSIDE to implementing RCV in any case.) Whether it's moving political discourse towards the middle (where things get done) or increasing the civility in our legislative bodies, or potentially saving effort & money by embedding run-off votes into an initial election, or encouraging voting because no vote is wasted, RCV is an idea whose time has come. PLEASE give Ranked Choice Voting a chance to place Virginia among the state leaders in 21st century elections. Do it now. There is nothing to be gained by waiting and everything to gain if this works the way it ought to. THANK YOU for your service in government, regardless of your political party, and THANK YOU for being a leader and voting to implement Ranked Choice Voting without delay! Respectfully,

The League of Women Voters of Virginia supports the expansion of ranked choice voting to Presidential Primaries, as described in SB270. We believe that ranked choice voting, or RCV, would make our elections more accessible, would promote nominees with broad support, and would ensure that every voter’s voice is heard. RCV often results in a more diverse slate of candidates who can run for office without the fear of being a “spoiler” or splitting the vote. RCV allows voters to express their choice of candidates fully, without worrying about “wasting their vote” if a preferred candidate drops out before election day, and without worrying about voting for the likely winner, rather than the candidate that most closely represents their personal views. RCV ensures that the winning candidate has the broad support of the majority of voters, rather than just a 22% or 34% plurality of voters. Additionally, our overseas and military families especially will benefit when RCV ballots are used. These voters are required to mail their ballots well ahead of election day and are impacted particularly by candidates dropping out of races before Election Day. We also appreciate all the work that this bill has received. The bill requires the Department of Election to confirm that all localities have the ability to conduct an RCV election. Additionally, the bill provides detailed processes, providing guidance to localities and the Department of Elections, on how to conduct an RCV election for a Presidential Primary. The League of Women Voters of Virginia asks this Subcommittee to report out SB270 to the full House P&E Committee.

As a resident of Rosslyn in Arlington County, Virginia, I am writing to express my strong support for Virginia Senate Bill (SB) 270, which advocates for the adoption of Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) in presidential primaries. This legislative move is particularly impactful for individuals like myself, who value the democratic process and recognize the benefits RCV offers to both military personnel overseas and civilians alike. The introduction of RCV is a significant advancement for those of us concerned with the logistical hurdles and disenfranchisement often experienced during absentee voting. For veterans and active duty members stationed abroad, RCV ensures that our vote remains influential even if our first-choice candidate becomes non-viable. This aspect of RCV is critical in primaries crowded with contenders, offering a solution to the common problem where a preferred candidate withdraws from the race, potentially rendering traditional votes ineffective. Furthermore, RCV streamlines the voting process for service members by eliminating the need for participation in potentially multiple rounds of primaries through absentee ballots. This consolidation into a single, decisive vote respects the unique time and logistical challenges faced by military voters, facilitating a more inclusive and participatory electoral process. SB 270 represents a forward-thinking approach to voting that not only enhances the voting experience for those of us serving overseas but also strengthens the democratic process by ensuring every vote counts and contributes to electing candidates who truly represent the majority's preference. By supporting this bill, Virginia acknowledges the sacrifices and challenges of its service members, affirming the state's commitment to upholding and enhancing democratic participation for all its residents.

Please allow elected representatives to implement Ranked Choice Voting in any municipality where the citizen-voters prefer it. The matter is simple and a validation of representative democracy in action. Thank You.

Rank choice voting (RCV) provides voters with the opportunity to vote for the candidate they believe is best to represent their individual interests. Currently a voter feels forced to vote for one of the two major parties to make any difference. For me, this is especially important today because the two major parties are the same on those issues I care about most, namely endless war and a total disregard for the explicit directives of the US Constitution. I think that over time RCV will provide the medium income voter some ability to influence legislation. Based on the so called Princeton study, it has been demonstrated that the medium income voter has zero influence on the policies that will become laws in the US Congress.

Dear Ma'am or Sir: I strongly support Ranked Choice Voting and request you do the same by supporting this bill. Ranked Choice Voting is the fairest way to ensure a candidate wins with a majority of voter support. It prevents a large minority from controlling the majority. This forces candidates to appeal to a majority of voters and not just a minority base. This changes the incentives for campaigning. Ranked Choice Voting also eliminates the spoiler affect. This mean candidates with a lower chance of winning an election are not discouraged from running for office. This increases the choice for voters, which is a good thing in a democracy. Please support Ranked Choice Voting and expand its use within Virginia.

I urge you to vote YES for SB270. The bill offers a transformative solution to the issue of polarized candidates in Virginia. By introducing a ranked-choice voting system, SB270 empowers voters to support candidates who truly align with their values, rather than feeling constrained by a "winner takes all" mentality. The evidence is clear: ranked-choice voting has been shown to reduce polarization, foster more civil campaigns, and ultimately lead to the election of candidates who better represent the majority of voters. As a result of RCV, we can expect more inclusive and diverse representation in government. I urge you to support SB270 and embrace a more equitable and representative electoral process for the benefit of all Virginians.

The attachment includes brief informational testimony on SB270.

P/E Subcommittee, BOTTOM LINE UP FRONT: SB270 POSITIVELY ACHIEVES GETTING MORE ACTIVE DUTY MILITARY BALLOTS COUNTED. On behalf of Veterans for All Voters, we explicitly and vociferously ask that you continue your support of Ranked Choice Voting through SB270. We steadfastly believe that the use of Ranked Choice Voting may be the most important and most necessary structural improvement to our electoral system right now! It brings more power to voters, promotes issue-based campaigning, brings consensus and balanced sanity back to our political discourse, AND IT ASSURES MORE ACTIVE DUTY MILITARY VOTERS GET COUNTED. It's not a Red thing or a Blue thing, it re-incentivizes consensus, and absolutely is the most elegant solution for our military voters. Veterans for All Voters asks that you PLEASE support SB270!!!

Thank you for providing the opportunity to express my support for SB270. As a former Soldier with close to 16 years of active service, I believe this bill will help decrease disenfranchisement amongst veteran voters by ensuring their votes are not lost or discarded due to the inadequacies and limits associated with overseas voting. Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) ensure all votes are counted, even if candidates suddenly drop from the race and the veteran has already mailed his or her ballot.

As a veteran based in Charlottesville, Virginia, who has experienced the challenges of voting through overseas ballots, I strongly support Virginia Senate Bill (SB) 270, especially due to its implications for Ranked Choice Voting (RCV). This bill, which allows political parties to use RCV in presidential primaries, is a game changer for former service members like me, who have been stationed far from home. RCV is crucial for veterans and active duty personnel overseas. Traditionally, voting while deployed presents logistical challenges, often leading to a feeling of disenfranchisement. With RCV, we can rank candidates in order of preference, mitigating the risk of our vote being wasted if our top choice is not viable. This is especially important in primaries where multiple candidates vie for nomination, and our preferred candidate may drop out before our ballot is even counted. Moreover, RCV simplifies the process of voting in primaries for overseas military personnel. Instead of navigating the complexities of absentee voting for multiple rounds of a primary, service members can make their voices heard in a single, comprehensive vote. This not only ensures greater participation but also respects the constraints of military duty, where time and resources for voting are limited. As sailors and soldiers stationed overseas, our ability to participate in the democratic process is often hindered by logistical and time constraints. SB 270, by implementing RCV, directly addresses these challenges, ensuring that our votes count and our voices are heard, regardless of where duty takes us. It's a step towards acknowledging and respecting the unique circumstances of military voters, reinforcing the democratic values we serve to protect.

Please vote NO on SB 270. Ranked choice voting should be opposed because it involves a method of tabulation that suppresses the popular vote. Under ranked choice voting, if the candidate with the most votes receives less than 50 percent of the votes, that candidate does not win, but must go on to another round of voting. Same with the second and third rounds, etc. Any method of tabulation that negates the popular vote, such as with a plurality win, suppresses the will of the voters and is undemocratic.

Dear committee members, I'm writing in support of SB270 which would give political parties the option to use ranked choice voting (RCV) in future presidential primaries. I am the Director of Research and Policy at FairVote, an organization that researches electoral reforms. We support RCV for presidential primaries because it lets primary voters navigate a crowded field, ensures every voter’s voice is heard even if their first-choice candidate withdraws just before the primary, and incentivizes presidential candidates to speak to issues important to Virginia voters in order to build the broadest coalition of support. Five state Democratic parties used RCV for presidential primaries in 2020, including Kansas, Alaska, Wyoming, and Hawaii for all voters and Nevada for early voters only. These states found that RCV preserves key benefits of caucuses, like allowing voters to “realign” with a second choice if their top choice candidate does not earn enough support to remain in the delegate race, while also modernizing the process with a primary that allows for greater participation. Voters in these states took advantage of the opportunity to rank multiple candidates, made very few ballot errors, and turned out in large numbers. In a year when nearly 3 million early voters in states without RCV cast ballots for presidential candidates who had already withdrawn by the time ballots were counted, RCV made more votes count. (See the report I authored on RCV in presidential primaries in 2020 at: https://fairvote.org/report/ranked_choice_voting_in_2020_presidential_primary_elections/) For Virginia, a state that votes on "Super Tuesday," RCV will be even more important next time either party has a highly competitive primary race. Candidates often drop out after early state primaries, sometimes just days before "Super Tuesday." In 2020, over 30,000 Democratic primary voters in Virginia cast their ballots for candidates who had already dropped out of the race. Similarly, 11,000 Republican primary voters did so in 2016. Looking ahead to 2028, it's likely at least one of the major parties will have a highly competitive primary field, and possibly both. RCV will help parties coalesce behind the nominee with broadest support, ensuring Virginia awards its delegates to the candidate with the most appeal in the Commonwealth. Additionally, RCV will benefit Virginia voters by giving them more choice on the ballot and protecting them from "wasted votes." I and my colleagues at FairVote would be happy to answer any questions. You can reach me at dotis@fairvote.org. Sincerely, Deb Otis Director of Research and Policy, FairVote dotis@fairvote.org

“I / We steadfastly believe that the use of Ranked Choice Voting may be the most important and most necessary structural improvement to our electoral system right now! It brings more power to voters, promotes issue-based campaigning, and brings consensus and balanced sanity back to our political discourse. Moreover, military voters have a better chance to get their vote counted! Please support SB270 as it moves back to the House... Respectfully, Mr. Charles E. Benz

I encourage you to support the use of Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) in presidential primaries. RCV rewards substantive campaigns and considerably reduces the typical fear mongering ads of today's polarizing political campaigns. R(RCV) ensures winners with a majority support which encourages our representatives to serve all constituents, not just a minority of voters.

I strongly support Ranked Choice Voting in all elections where there are more tan 2 candidates. This system of voting will ensure that winning candidate receives the support of more than 50% of the voters. In the last election for City Council in Virginia Beach 4 out of 7 district Council seats were decided by less than 50%. In my district it was about 37%. I am sure in many primary elections where there are often more than 2 candidates the winners often receive less than 50% of the vote. If ranked Choice Voting is used in an election, candidate's would have to appeal to a broader electorate and result in a more centrist winner. Haven't we had enough of the negativity in our elections? I served 31 years in the US Navy flying off of aircraft carriers and leading sailors in defense of this Nation. In fact my last duty station was on the USS Eisenhower now engaged in defending the interests of this Nation. I took an oath to defend the Constitution of United States. I think we are at a crossroads that demands elected officials stand up and do the same to preserve our democracy. Ranked Choice Voting will put us back on that path. Respectfully, Captain D. Stubbs, USN retired

SB 270 is a commonsense bill that gives political parties the option of using Ranked Choice Voting in publicly funded Presidential Primary elections. Using Ranked Choice Voting in primary elections will ensure nominees of political parties will have the support of the majority of the primary election voters. Using Ranked Choice Voting is especially important for early voters, voters who use mail-in ballots, and military members and their dependents who mail their ballots from overseas locations. By ranking candidates, voters’ preferences will “count” even if their #1 choice drops out of the primary election race after they vote early or mail their mail-in ballot. Please vote YES on SB 270.

Hello, my name is LaTwyla Mathias, and I am the Executive Director of Progress Virginia. We support SB270 and ranked choice voting because it gives voters more of a choice in the Democratic process. Ranked choice voting has been shown to increase voter turnout by 10%. Ranked choice voting also ensures that the candidate with the broadest support wins, and has even been shown to reduce negative campaigning. We hope you will pass SB270 to allow ranked choice voting in presidential primaries so that the candidate with the broadest level of support wins and that voters have more choice when it comes to our elections.

Virginia has a proud history of providing parties wide latitude in how they select their nominees for office. They can choose from a wide variety of options from closed conventions to open public primaries. This measure simply provides one additional option for parties to nominate their strongest candidate. Please vote yes and allow parties the OPTION of using ranked choice voting for Presidential primaries. Thank you for your service to our state. Cordially, Bo Harmon Leesburg, VA 20175

I write in support of SB270 to use Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) in Presidential primary elections beginning in 2028. Voters will be able to vote for the candidate(s) that most closely align with the voter's beliefs and values. Voters will not see their votes thrown in the trash because their selected candidate(s) drops out of the race the day before election day. This is especially important for overseas voters, including our military voters. Please vote YES on SB270 and send this bill to the full Committee.