Public Comments for: HB118 - Discovery materials or evidence; allows accused to request the Commonwealth to copy or photograph.
I support this bill. As someone who went through the legal system and having a case where evidence was destroyed, statements were questionable due to suggestiveness from the detective of the case - I believe there needs to be more transparency of such evidence before going to trial. People mostly go to court with public defenders and therefore are most of the time at a disadvantage not because the PD is bad, but because they are so overworked - the attention needed isn’t always given. By law, ignorance of the law isn’t a factor in anything - so a defendant who has zero knowledge of such things can’t properly defend himself so must rely on the PD. The PD should get all relevant and necessary information that could help defend their client.
I also support this because the more access we have to evidence, the more we are able to build a proper defense. There have been times where the evidence could have proven a person's innocence but it was swept under the rug or not released in favor of something that helped gain a conviction. The whole story should be known, not only the way they want it told.
If you are accused of a crime not only should you be able to face your accuser you should also be able to see the evidence against you. I also believe that the accused should be able to be present during any and all meetings between the prosecutor and their lawyer . The accused should not be arrested and held without bond unless it has something to do with a violent crime and even then should not be housed with people who are serving a sentence even though it is in the law it is not followed .
Discovery discrepancies are rampant throughout several cases that I know of. Please pass this bill to allow for more transparency. Both sides should be able to see and request all evidence both before and after trial so that they can accurately represent their case!
HB 118 is important legislation for us to pass in order to increase access to criminal justice defense and reduce prosecution chicanery. Any politician who votes against this bill will get put in the bucket of undesirable politicians.